In 1961, dialysis could save lives, but it was available to only a handful of patients. That summer, seven Seattle citizens—a pastor, a surgeon, a lawyer, a labor leader, a housewife, a banker, and a politician—were asked to perform an unprecedented act of public service. Privately known as the “Life or Death Committee,” they were given the task of deciding which gravely ill patients would receive this groundbreaking treatment—and which ones would be denied.

Within the committee’s closed world, each member carries private burdens. Among them: a beloved councilman with a devastating secret; a housewife starved for purpose; a pastor haunted by his father’s violence; and a surgeon whose service in the Korean War left him unable to feel. As hidden connections emerge and loyalties shift, their fragile alliance is threatened by scrutiny from Life magazine and the compromises they have made in the name of fairness.

With uncanny psychological insight and gripping narrative force, Medoff confronts urgent questions of responsibility, conscience, and what it means to be a good person. Sweeping yet intimate, The Life or Death Committee is an ambitious novel about secrecy, moral judgment, and the choices that bind us to one another and forever alter how we understand ourselves.

The Life or Death Committee

Who has the right to live? Who should decide?

Bestselling author Jillian Medoff explores the human cost of impossible choices in a dazzling novel inspired by a controversial true story.

REVIEWS & PRAISE

Rave review in Kirkus: “This well-documented chapter in American medical history springs to life under Medoff’s thoughtful shaping of provocative subject matter….Medoff shines in building complex portraits of average people both burdened and elevated by morally fraught work…. The novel is imbued with a kind of refined melancholy that highlights the moral ambiguity of the characters confronting their personal failures in ordinary life, while on Thursdays, they play God. A remarkable moment in history, and the birth of bioethics, is brought to the human level in this fascinating page-turner.”

Starred, rave review in Library Journal: “An important, heartbreaking book.”

Gorgeous review in Shelf Awareness: “Her literary skill is most evident in the chapters she devotes to illuminating the lives of each of her committee members…a vivid fictional account of a group charged with deciding which patients would receive experimental dialysis treatment for end-stage kidney disease.”

Terrific review in Publishers Weekly: “Medoff bases this illuminating drama on the true story of a group of seven volunteers…it’s a quietly arresting character study.”

BEHIND THE BOOK

Learn how Jillian discovered the real Life-or-Death Committee, researched its history, and transformed that real-life story into fiction. Read the Author’s Note.

Jillian recorded a promotional video for Harper’s library marketing team to explain the novel’s who, what, where, when, and why.

The Life or Death Committee is a deep dive into the relationship between power and empathy. To read this book is to imagine yourself at the committee table, with the ability to help only a small number of those in critical need. Scene after scene, the question resurfaces: What would you do? I loved this bold, complex, character-driven novel. — Patrick Ryan, NY Times bestselling author of Buckeye

The Life or Death Committee is the story of impossible choices made by ordinary people. Jillian Medoff has built us a gorgeous historical treasure box of a book. Expansive and intricate all at once, this depiction of a rapidly changing healthcare system and the people at its center is a propulsive examination of what morality really means when you’re deciding the fate of a neighbor. — Lily Brooks-Dalton, critically acclaimed, bestselling author of The Light Pirate and Ruins

Beautifully written and full of suspense, The Life or Death Committee tells a captivating, powerful, and deeply human story about the agonizing moral consequences of our decisions. Jillian Medoff has revealed a forgotten chapter of twentieth-century American culture with compassion and a masterful command of storytelling. — Bruce Holsinger, bestselling author of Culpability (Oprah’s Book Club)